"How does a particular story reflect boy's progression into manhood?"
"Clever Hans" is interesting to me because while I was reading it, I assumed that Hans had to be a young boy due to his blatant stupidity and lack of common sense. Upon reading the final line of the tale, "That was how Hans lost his bride," I was surprised to discover that Hans, at least by the end of the tale, was an adult. I think this story says a lot about how men are perceived. Hans' lack of growth from the beginning of the tale (it's unclear as to how old he is at the beginning) to the end implies that man's ability to discern logically is somewhat stunted. Hans listens to his mother's suggestions and always utilizes them "next time," but never grows wise enough to discern when her suggestions are appropriate. Hans grows from a stupid boy to a stupid man who ultimately loses his bride because of his inability to use common sense.
In addition to lacking common sense, Hans continues to faithfully listen to his mother as if he were still a child. Whatever his mother tells him to do, Hans obediently does it. His growth into manhood is so stunted that there really doesn't seem to be a difference between his childhood and adulthood. It's difficult to discern any change and really makes the reader wonder if there is any progression into manhood at all for Clever Hans, which makes him an interesting choice when studying the progression from boyhood to manhood.
Fairy Tales 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I don't think that Hans is ever a man in this story, by both mental development and age standards. It feels as though he is in that awkward adolescent stage between boyhood and manhood, and he has not yet connected the "Mother Knows Best" mentality to the "This Is How Things Work" knowledge.
ReplyDeleteEven though Hans is decidedly silly for applying his mother's advice to the wrong situations, the story almost seems like it can be read as a warning to never follow a mother's advice. (And we definitely have those in abundance - the mom often gets a really bad rep for giving awful suggestions.)